Tuesday, July 18, 2006

 

Prophetic Resistance: Islamic Scholar Amina Wadud



Controversial scholar Amina Wadud writes on the place of women in Islam


One of the great fallacies of this historical period is that all of the Islamic world is opposed to the rights of women and that the religion itself denies full humanity to women. It is easy for us to condemn all of Islam as being anti-feminine given the realities of laws and traditional practices that are destructive of the rights, dignity and freedoms of women and girls such as FGM, discriminatory property rights laws; hijab; stoning, etc. But, what if all these practices were aberrations or destructive misreadings of the sacred texts of Islam. Controversial Islamic scholar Amina Wadud makes this very case in her new book and in a recent interview on WNYC's Bryan Lehrer show.

Amina Wadud made the headlines last year when she led a prayer for a group of Muslims in New York. It was a protest of the tradition that forbids female imams in Islam and it drew condemnation from conservative Muslims as well praise from secular feminists. She outlines her arguments for change in a new book, Inside the Gender Jihad: Women's Reform in Islam.

Comments:
"It is easy for us to condemn all of Islam as being anti-feminine given the realities of laws and traditional practices that are destructive of the rights, dignity and freedoms of women and girls such as FGM, discriminatory property rights laws; hijab; stoning, etc"

In which way is a peice of cloth on ones head "destructive" for female rights? I don't think you've understood any of what Ms Wadud has to say
 
Thanks for your comment. I cannot admit to studying Wadud in any real detail. My comments are only indicative of my own opinions about traditional practices - which should be taken with a huge grain of salt. I realize that there are women are argue that traditional Islamic dress protects them from the unwanted sexual gaze of men. I feel that women should have the right to be seen and to dress in any way they please and should live in societies where despite their appearence it is not acceptable to inflict unwanted sexual attention on them. As such a piece of cloth on one's head may not be destructive of a person's rights...a society, system that demands that piece be in place in public at all times seems to be constrictive if not destructive of personal freedom.
 
Post a Comment

<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?